Overall nice and did the job for us. The neighborhood is gorgeous.
But only the main bedroom has air conditioning, though the listing states "air conditioned." Since the rest of the cottage receives only natural ventilation through the screened clerestory, we had to rely on the ceiling fans. We were fine, especially since the weather was very mild during our early April stay, but others may not be comfortable.
We had a problem with baby spiders looking for food in the kitchen. We managed them, and since we were only staying for four nights it wasn't a big deal, but other guests may object.
The indoor shower needs an overhaul - it works - barely.
The lack of glass in the clerestory meant we could hear the neighbors and the vehicles - sometimes too well. Because the road is a shore access, it's faily busy, and some of the vehicles are LOUD - I thought I was back in Indiana. :-)
We met and talked to Scott briefly when we arrived - he's very friendly! We didn't approach him about our issues, because for our short stay, and only using the cottage for sleeping and breakfast, it wasn't worth the fuss, but someone wanting to stay for a longer period and use the cottage more may want to consider these issues. Otherwise, recommended!