My husband and I got married in the Finger Lakes in 2017 and this was an anniversary trip.
Pros/cons to the property. I do agree with a recent reviewer that the property itself was not the cleanest. The fridge and floor were sticky. There was only a broom available, no vacuum, so we did our best to clean with that. In terms of the exterior, there is a light on the back of the house and a motion sensor light in the front, but it is not very bright, so I would strongly recommend bringing a flashlight, especially if you need to bring your dog out at night. It did get cold in the house but there are small space heaters that helped.
Pros - house provides linens/towels, space heaters, etc. We didn’t use the loft area at all, but it is a nice size if you have guests. Property is very private. Overall location is absolutely perfect. Very close to Watkins Glen State Park (you can see the waterfall as you’re driving into town), the Franklin Street strip has a ton of eateries and a nice brewery, and it’s a 20 min drive to some fantastic wineries along Seneca Lake!! I imagine this place would be even better in the summer time. Would stay again.